A planning inspector has granted 40 homes on farmland off Pampisford Road, Great Abington, after finding the council has not shown a five-year housing supply.
Up to 40 homes can be built on farmland off Pampisford Road in Great Abington after a planning inspector overturned the district council’s refusal. The decision, issued on 23 October, also found that South Cambridgeshire has not shown it has a five-year supply of land for housing.
That second finding is the one that matters beyond the village. The council has published a statement disputing it, and at least two other large appeals in the district turn on the same argument.
What was decided
The inspector, Gemma Pannell, allowed the appeal by Rosconn Group and granted outline planning permission for “residential development of up to 40 dwellings and associated infrastructure”. Only the access was fixed at this stage. The layout, design and landscaping come later. (appeal decision 6005101)
The council’s planning officers had refused the application, reference 25/03315/OUT, under delegated powers. The council said it refused it because the site lies outside the village, in the countryside, and is not allocated for housing in the Local Plan. (South Cambridgeshire District Council, 6 November)
The appeal was heard at a two-day hearing on 11 and 12 August, with a site visit on the second day. The inspector decided it under the new national planning rules published that August.
What the permission includes
The site is 2.61 hectares of grade 3a farmland, most recently grazed by sheep. It lies west of the houses on the High Street and wraps around Moorfield Close. The legal agreement and conditions attached to the decision secure:
- 16 affordable homes, 40% of the total, for rent and shared ownership
- two serviced plots for people who want to build their own home
- homes on the northern edge limited to one and a half storeys
- £72,800 towards the Linton Greenway cycle route between Great Abington and Babraham
- £117,749.22 towards play equipment at the Recreation Ground, run by the parish council
- £432.73 a home towards moving and expanding the Cambridge ambulance hub
- contributions to swimming and indoor sport at Sawston and Linton, the Village Institute, outdoor sport and the village allotments
The developer had argued that several of these payments were not needed. The inspector found each one necessary. Rosconn has three years to apply for approval of the detailed design. (appeal decision, paragraphs 70 to 112 and condition 1)
Why the inspector disagreed with the council
Councils that cannot show five years’ worth of housing land lose much of their ability to refuse homes outside village boundaries. At the hearing, the two sides argued over the figure for Cambridge and South Cambridgeshire together, the basis both Local Plans use.
- The council’s own figure on a 2025 base was 4.92 years, short of five.
- The developer put it at 3.49 years.
- The council’s newer figure on a 2026 base was 5.59 years. The inspector said it rested on expected, not final, completions for 2025-26.
- After the hearing, the council switched to counting South Cambridgeshire on its own. That gave 7.83 years for the district and 2.72 years for Cambridge.
The inspector did not accept the switch. She said the joint approach was built into the adopted plans and was the basis on which the evidence was tested. She also noted that the council’s supply leans on large sites such as Northstowe, where 134 homes had already been taken out of the five-year forecast. (appeal decision, paragraphs 24 to 33)
She added that even at 7.83 years she would have allowed the scheme. Both sides agreed there is an unmet need for 708 affordable homes a year across Greater Cambridge, and a shortfall of 440 self-build plots. On that basis the benefits “substantially outweigh” the harm. (appeal decision, paragraphs 18 to 20 and 125 to 127)
She found a low level of harm to the setting of Old Farm, a grade II listed house whose thatched roof can be seen from the site. Farm Cottage and the Cottage to the West of Farm Cottage, also grade II, would suffer a very low level of harm. She judged the public benefits enough to outweigh both.
What the council says
The council said on 6 November that it does not consider the decision a precedent. It points to the government’s own Housing Delivery Test, which shows the district built 4,475 homes in the three years to 2024-25 against a target of 3,032.
| Year | Government target | Homes built |
|---|---|---|
| 2022-23 | 975 | 1,457 |
| 2023-24 | 1,018 | 1,281 |
| 2024-25 | 1,039 | 1,737 |
(Housing Delivery Test: 2025 measurement, as quoted by the council)
Cllr Henry Batchelor, the council’s lead cabinet member for planning, said: “We have tried and failed to convince the Government to act to fix an anomaly in the way they treat Greater Cambridge when it comes to these housing targets.”
He added: “We will therefore continue to resist speculative development that would undermine our carefully planned approach to growth that communities have helped shape.” (South Cambridgeshire District Council)
The appeals that come next
The same supply argument is in play on two bigger schemes. Both are listed in the appeals report to the council’s Planning Committee on 11 November. (appeals report, 11 November 2026)
- Up to 100 homes off Horseheath Road, Linton, refused unanimously by the committee in July. The appeal was lodged on 2 October. Our story on the Linton appeal sets out the developer’s 3.64-year supply claim.
- Up to 110 homes between Hinton Way and Mingle Lane, Great Shelford and Stapleford. A hearing is booked for 12 January 2027, and the council’s statement is due on 17 November.
What it means for you
If you live in Great Abington, the next stage is a reserved matters application for the layout, house types and landscaping. It will be published on the Greater Cambridge planning portal, and you can comment on it there. Our South Cambs planning news page explains how to find and follow an application.
For the rest of the district, developers can now cite this decision on other village-edge sites, although the council says it sets no precedent. The question will stay open until a later inspector rules on it, or the new Greater Cambridge Local Plan is adopted.
Have your say