Councillors approved 34 affordable homes on the sawmill site behind 56 Histon Road, Cottenham, on 11 November. The parish council and 10 neighbours objected.
Updated 14 November: the Planning Committee approved the scheme on 11 November, subject to the decision notice being issued. Our report on the decision has what happens next.
Planning officers are recommending approval for 34 affordable homes on a sawmill site behind 56 Histon Road in Cottenham. South Cambridgeshire’s Planning Committee will decide the application on Wednesday 11 November.
It is the first application to reach the committee through the new “Gateway” panel, which replaced the right of parish councils to call schemes in on 31 October. The panel referred it for one reason: Anglian Water’s objection that Cambridge’s sewage works is already over capacity. (agenda, Planning Committee 11 November)
What is proposed
Living Space Housing wants to knock down the house at 56 Histon Road, use its plot for a new access road, and clear the sawmill buildings behind it. The site covers 1.43 hectares, mostly outside the village boundary and in the Green Belt. The application was first described as 41 homes; the amended scheme is 34. (officers’ report, 24/03961/FUL)
All 34 would be affordable, kept affordable in perpetuity, and let or sold to people with a local connection to Cottenham. The proposed split is:
| Tenure | 1-bed | 2-bed | 3-bed | 4-bed | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Social rent | 8 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 8 |
| Affordable rent | 0 | 7 | 5 | 2 | 14 |
| Shared ownership | 0 | 6 | 6 | 0 | 12 |
Officers say the share of shared ownership should come down so the mix matches local need. The final split would be fixed in the legal agreement.
The homes would be set around a central green with a drainage basin and a play area. Each house would have two parking spaces; each flat would have one.
Why officers support it
Officers treat the scheme as a “rural exception site”: affordable housing on land that would not normally be built on, to meet a village’s own need. That status also makes it acceptable in the Green Belt under national policy.
The evidence they rely on:
- 129 Cottenham households were on the council’s housing register in October 2026, 72 of them needing a one-bedroom home.
- A 2022 housing need survey for the village found unmet need for affordable homes, even after the rural exception site now being built at 34 Histon Road.
- The sawmill runs under a 1985 permission personal to one man. When that use ends, the permission says the land goes back to farming, so officers accept the loss of the business.
The legal agreement would include £321,872.22 for district facilities such as outdoor sport, community space and green space. Separate sums of £90,044 for early years places, £341,585 for primary school places and £9,100 for libraries are also listed.
The objections
Cottenham Parish Council objects. Its points, as summarised in the report:
- it backs the Lead Local Flood Authority’s original concerns about the drainage design
- the scheme relies on a new sewer that another developer would have to build
- it offers a 10% gain in wildlife habitat, below the district’s 20% policy
- dropped kerbs and tactile paving are not a proper crossing of Histon Road
- parked cars on Histon Road would block drivers’ view at the new junction
Ten neighbours have objected, mainly over flooding. The site itself is at low risk, but homes on Histon Road to the south sit in areas of high, medium and low surface water flood risk and have flooded before. The flood authority and the internal drainage board have both withdrawn their objections after revised drainage details. (Gateway assessment form, 21 October)
Why Anglian Water objects
Anglian Water has lodged a holding objection to all new applications that would drain to the Cambridge Water Recycling Centre. It did so after the government decided in August 2025 not to fund a new water recycling centre for Greater Cambridge, which was meant to add capacity for growth.
The figures Anglian Water supplied show the works treated more than its permitted daily flow in 2023 and 2024, and less in 2025. Environment Agency data in the report records 74 storm overflow spills in 2023, lasting 1,476 hours, falling to 23 in 2024 and four in 2025. Officers say that suggests untreated sewage has reached the River Cam in conditions other than storms.
The applicant puts the scheme’s extra flow at about 0.04% of the works’ daily load. Officers call that “negligible” and say it does not justify refusal. (officers’ report, paragraphs 19.11 to 19.22)
How the Gateway panel dealt with it
Under the new rules, officers decide most major applications unless a two-person panel, one councillor and one officer, sends them to committee. The councillor on this panel was Cllr Anna Bradnam.
The form records that the scheme did not raise a significant local economic, social or environmental issue, the first test. It did meet the second test, a significant planning matter, solely because of Anglian Water’s objection. The form notes that “the number of objections received is not, by itself, a reason for referral”. Our story on the end of parish call-in explains how the new system works.
Also on Wednesday’s agenda
- Waste Management Park, Ely Road, Landbeach: the district council’s own application to change the approved plans and wildlife conditions for its solar farm there. It goes to committee because the council is the applicant.
- 25 Denmark Road, Cottenham: an application for a certificate that proposed works are lawful.
What it means for you
The meeting starts at 10am on Wednesday 11 November in the Council Chamber at South Cambridgeshire Hall, Cambourne. It is open to the public and broadcast live on YouTube. Our South Cambs planning news page explains how to follow an application.
Have your say